The 2-Axis Political Model and Global Warming

Confusion is definitely centered in the Republican quadrant. Via Dan Kahan  who wants us to focus on the rainbow effect. But to me the most striking thing about this pattern is the rarity of deep confusion outside the top left quadrant. Cover that quadrant with white paper and mentally extrapolate. Then look at the data again.

two_dimensions_color

 

 

Comments:

  1. I've been staring at this. The left hand key to colors is a little confusing, as it looks like it might be a label for the y axis. A closer look reveals egalitariansim hierarchy. It's interesting to me that climate deniers often identify their targets as hierarchical, when they themselves rarely diverge from opinions handed down from "on high". That is, the ones that are not busy spreading disinformation on purpose, and since they are informed enough to know they are lying, that's a real study.

  2. I don't know where those specific labels came from either. I've asked over at the original post. The initial data only seemed to have a liberal conservative axis. This grid graph looks a bit like it's just assuming those two axes from the single liberalconservative one (hence the trumpet shape). Could be wrong, often am.

  3. Dan, the original graph doesn't show the way that humpback distorts. Picture = 1000 words?

    It is, however, an odd and subjective evaluation, and perhaps not particularly useful to the true problem, which is getting people to acknowledge there is a problem and work together for the common weal, acknowledging that we will all lose if we set ourselves in opposition to reality.

  4. Yes it is linked in the OP
    http://www.culturalcognition.net/storage/two_dimensions_color.png

    and it gets worse
    http://www.culturalcognition.net/blog/2013/1/11/amazingly-cool-important-article-on-virulence-of-ideological.html


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.